September 18, 2023

Top Human Capital Management (HCM) Software for 2024

Written by
Why is TechnologyAdvice Free?
Tags: HR

Our picks for the top human capital management (HCM) software include:

Sep. 18, 2023: Jessica Dennis restructured the page to put our expert recommendations front and center. We also added dynamic design elements to improve the visual flow of information and clarified the reasons behind our choices.

We picked our recommendations with you in mind.

First, we evaluated several of the most popular human capital management solutions on the market today. We used vendor demos, free trials, technical documentation, and user reviews from customers like you to compile our research.

We then narrowed our selections to platforms that address your top-of-mind concerns, such as advanced analytics, automations, and customization. As the market changes, we reevaluate our choices so you always receive the best insight for your purchasing decision.

What is the top HCM software?

Human capital management (HCM) solutions support strategic alignment between a company’s workforce and overarching business objectives. An HCM platform’s broad toolset helps companies develop and leverage employee strengths on a broader scale to increase the return on investment (ROI) of the workforce.

Large companies that track and manage data in various departments outside HR need an HCM platform to acquire more complex analytical insights. These insights drive compensation strategies and succession planning, to name just a couple of examples.

These top HCM software solutions are designed to help businesses optimize their workforces and develop internal talent, but if none of these solutions fit your needs, check out our HR Software Guide.

ADP Enterprise HR: Best for scalability


Pros

  • Add-on functionalities to scale as needed.
  • AI-generated “headlines” for data digests from ADP DataCloud.
  • Internal and external benchmarking data.
  • Variety of customizable dashboards.

Cons

  • Compliance services rather than built-in, automated compliance features.
  • Add-ons drive up cost compared to all-inclusive alternatives.
  • No built-in expense management to ensure budget-aligned HR strategy.

ADP Enterprise HR is designed for companies of 1,000 or more employees, offering customizable payroll, compliance services for taxes and HR, and ADP DataCloud for strategic HR management.

ADP Data Cloud

ADP DataCloud powers ADP Enterprise HR’s analytical capabilities and helps companies identify workforce trends based on internal data, such as skills gaps or staffing shortages. It also provides benchmarking insights based on external, industry-standard data related to HR, payroll, recruitment, and other areas.

DataCloud draws from market averages and aggregated HR data from ADP’s broader client database. Pulling internal and external metrics helps HR leaders understand how their organization stacks up against competitors. ADP DataCloud’s storyboards also provide data visualization to help HR leaders develop and refine data-driven HCM strategies.

ADP Enterprise HR makes strategic HR tools accessible to smaller businesses that want core HR functions as well as higher-level analytics that more expensive, comprehensive HCM platforms provide.

Modular set-up

For added functionality, customers may integrate the platform with other software or use ADP’s own add-on tools, such as:

  • Recruiting and onboarding.
  • Talent management to develop employees, track their performance, manage compensation, and conduct succession planning.
  • Benefits administration streamlined with ACA compliance.
  • Time and attendance to manage labor costs, simplify compliance, and configure automatic scheduling.

Alternatively, ADP customers can upgrade to ADP Vantage HCM which bundles core and auxiliary functions within one platform.

The ADP Enterprise HR platform shows dashboards on both desktop and mobile devices with compensation benchmarking data.
ADP Enterprise HR features ADP DataCloud which is full of customizable, easy-to-understand dashboards that deliver critical workforce data. Credit: ADP

ADP Enterprise HR does not disclose its pricing. You must contact their sales team for a quote.

ADP Enterprise HR stands out from the other vendors here in terms of the add-on options that other HCMs already include. This allows companies to scale up their capabilities as needed, adding tactical tools like recruiting later if they choose.

isolved: Best for budget-aligned HR strategy


Pros

  • Included features that other vendors offer as add-ons.
  • Expense management.
  • Predictive analytics with natural language processing.

Cons

  • Lack of automation in identifying and matching talent with job openings.
  • No external benchmarking data like ADP.
  • No compensation strategy tools.

isolved’s HCM platform includes HR and payroll, talent acquisition, workforce management, and talent management modules, so its bundled capabilities might provide cost savings compared to ADP’s modular add-on setup.

Expense management

Its workforce management tools, in particular, include expense management. As a company invests money in the initiatives that support its strategy, isolved’s expense management keeps track of overall expenditure on people-focused initiatives to ensure it aligns with the company’s budgeting goals and policies.

For example, expense management helps track cash flow for expenses, such as reimbursements for employee meals or tuition, that support employee engagement at company events or employees’ professional development. As such, expense management connects HR with accounting and tracks infrequent, one-off expenses. Payroll, in contrast, has its own separate reporting and analytics on employee wages and salaries.

isolved’s expense management also automates approvals instead of requiring multiple manual approvals. That’s a win for the employee because the reimbursement process is simplified and expedited, and it’s a win for the company as well because it keeps the employee happy while staying compliant and within budget.

Predictive people analytics

isolved’s AI-powered people analytics allow HR leaders to visualize workforce metrics, such as average tenure, gender ratio, and more, to get a better understanding of the current workforce and build a strategic HR strategy. The platform provides comprehensive benchmark data to forecast attrition at the department or employee level.

People analytics draws on historical trends within the company’s internal data and predicts how that historical data might unfold in a specified future time period. Predictive modeling in isolved is like a sandbox where HR leaders can focus on factors that have the biggest impact on the future of human resource management. For example, users can model different compensation scenarios to understand the relationship between compensation strategy and turnover. In this way, isolved’s people analytics tool enables HR to test out a strategy before executing it.

isolved platform displays multiple bar and pie graphs to visualize metrics like turnover, tenure, and number of employees by department.
iSolved features a user-friendly interface to retrieve HR metrics via query or natural language processing. Credit: iSolved

isolved does not disclose pricing on its website. However, it does provide a menu of modules and features to choose from. After selecting the products you are interested in, you can request pricing. Typically your price will be on a per employee, per month (PEPM) basis.

isolved expense and people analytics features are a main draw for companies needing to match overall business strategy with their budget. By forecasting data like turnover, companies can determine where to allocate funds to make the biggest impact on company culture, such as recruitment efforts or employee engagement.

Paycor: Best for succession planning


Pros

  • Benchmarking based on internal and external data.
  • Governmental data for macro-level comparisons.
  • Compensation planning with scenario testing for equitable, competitive compensation practices.
  • Career management tool to support succession planning.
  • Career management, talent development, and LMS as trifecta for optimal employee experience and retention.

Cons

  • Limited reporting and analytics customization.
  • Lack of natural language processing to navigate analytics.
  • Limited predictive analytics.

Paycor is a comprehensive HCM platform that serves as a one-stop shop for employees, managers, HR, and company leaders. It has built-in, customizable expense management, compensation planning, and career management tools.

People analytics

Paycor analytics provides benchmarking data from external as well as internal data sources to track how a company is doing in terms of employee retention or compensation, for example. Unlike ADP, Paycor leverages EEOC government data rather than data from other Paycor customers. Government data provides a more macro-level view of how a company stacks up, while ADP can provide more industry-specific comparisons.

Paycor’s analytics module provides answers to hundreds of pre-built questions about a company’s workforce but doesn’t offer customizable reports, so it won’t be able to answer specific questions an HR leader or manager might have. It also offers predictive analytics for employee turnover, absences, and more, based on the company’s historical data. Paycor’s analytics interface is query-based, meaning it doesn’t accommodate varied interactions like isolved analytics does through natural language processing (NLP).

Compensation planning

Paycor helps companies make informed decisions about how much to pay and how often to reward employees. Paycor’s compensation planning tool syncs with its people analytics tool to monitor pay equity and help HR leaders make sense of compensation trends that inform equitable and competitive compensation decisions.

Before implementing a compensation strategy, HR and company leaders can test scenarios to see how pay increases impact the rest of the business. Upon making a data-informed decision about how to act on compensation strategy, Paycor takes it from there through customized automated workflows based on rules that HR creates. These rules can be based on factors like start date or department.

Career management

Paycor’s career management solution is distinct from but related to its performance-oriented talent development tool. The career management tool supports a company’s succession planning efforts that involve upskilling, developing, and ultimately promoting employees from within.

In Paycor, HR can set up role profiles to give employees a clear understanding of their current roles and what they need to do to move up in the organization. Employees can take assessments that gauge their readiness for a promotion or role change. Knowing where an employee stands and what possibilities await them incentivizes employees to work toward their professional goals and removes the guesswork about their future with the organization.

Career management informs employee-manager interactions in the talent development module as well as employee activity in the learning management system.

The Paycor platform shows an employee's current role plus competencies that employees must gain for future roles.
Paycor’s career management software shows each employee what their current role entails and what they need to do to level up to the next position. Credit: Paycor

For businesses with 1–50 employees, the starting price is $99 per month plus $5 PEPM. For businesses with over 50 employees, you will need to contact Paycor for a customized quote.

Paycor combines advanced analytics with government benchmarking data to ensure compensation, recruitment, and talent strategies remain competitive. Adding this with Paycor’s career management features also means companies can support employee growth while developing successors to preserve and carry on the company’s mission.

Oracle Fusion Cloud HCM: Best for strategic workforce planning


Pros

  • Internal talent promotion through opportunity marketplace.
  • Comprehensive data integration and modeling capabilities across HR, finance, and operations.
  • Collaborative strategic workforce planning.
  • Built-in “My Wellness” module to positively influence employee wellbeing.
  • Compensation management benchmarking data based on role and location.

Cons

  • Compensation management lacks modeling capabilities.

Oracle Fusion Cloud HCM helps companies prepare and navigate change as they scale up. Within Oracle’s HCM platform, customers get tools for:

  • HR.
  • Payroll.
  • Talent management.
  • Workforce management.

Dynamic Skills

This is an AI-driven feature that helps fortify a company’s workforce with the skills it needs to contribute to organizational goals. The skills the system recommends and assigns to users adapt and respond over time based on the organization’s skills landscape and continued employee interaction.

Dynamic Skills hosts an inventory of skills and job data tailored to a company’s culture and industry to ensure employees develop relevant skills. The system assigns skills to employee profiles as well as job candidate profiles, and employees can earn skills by taking assessments.

This differs from the Learning module, which is Oracle’s LMS and features courses and training. It functions instead as a skills database from which employees collect skills and endorse others’ skills, managers identify employees who are ready for promotion, and leaders identify and address skills gaps.

Workforce planning

Oracle Fusion Cloud enables workforce modeling and predictions to anticipate employees who are at risk of leaving the organization and to see what might happen if someone gets promoted or takes extensive time off.

Oracle stands out in terms of predictive people analytics because it shows the impact that changes have not just in HR but in finance and operations as well. It also enables collaborative strategic workforce planning where organization leaders can create and edit planning scenarios at the same time.

Oracle's platform displays the variance dashboard with tables, bar graphs, and line graphs comparing current headcount with what-if headcount.
Oracle Fusion Cloud HCM enables strategic workforce planning by modeling out different “what-if” scenarios for their effect on HR, finance, and operations. Credit: Oracle

Oracle HCM’s Base Cloud Service costs $15 PEPM with a minimum of 500 employees and a three-year contract. This means you will pay at least $7,500 monthly, even if you have less than 500 employees. The price also does not include Oracle’s one-time product implementation or consultation.

The base fee is the minimum requirement to access Oracle HCM; every module incurs an additional PEPM cost. Some modules, like payroll, also have a minimum requirement of 1,000 employees.Check out Oracle’s Fusion Cloud Service Global Price List to estimate the cost for your needed features.

Oracle Fusion Cloud HCM leverages AI and companies’ historic data to forecast future events. This allows companies to take a more proactive approach to planning company initiatives — like reorganizations, global expansions, recruitment strategies, or acquisitions — while still maintaining a healthy and happy workforce.

Workday HCM: Best for compensation strategy and execution


Pros

  • Collaborative compensation planning.
  • Pay equity dashboards.
  • Concrete tools for building and improving a compensation package.
  • Recruiting-focused workforce planning.

Cons

  • Lacks the predictive modeling capabilities that Paycor’s compensation management has.
  • Workforce planning lacks the collaborative elements that Oracle includes.

Workday provides CHROs with high-level insight into how the makeup of the workforce affects revenue growth and resilience in the face of change.

Workforce planning

Workday’s Adaptive Planning unites HR, finance, and operations data to plan and prepare for workforce changes. Users can:

  • Model workforce dynamics and test cost impact.
  • Identify and close skills gaps across business units and functions.
  • Monitor open positions and the cost of filling them vs leaving them vacant.

Workday has recruiting-focused workforce planning tools. These inform recruiting strategy by delivering data about current and needed skills capacity by location which is great for companies with geographically dispersed workforces. HR, in collaboration with managers, can decide the best course of action, be it training, hiring, or reassigning employees.

Workday’s workforce planning tools are quite similar to Oracle’s, however, they lack collaboration. This makes a difference in more democratically-led organizations that take a variety of key stakeholders’ perspectives and ideas into consideration.

Also read: Workday vs Oracle HCM

Compensation management

Workday takes a collaborative approach to its compensation management by allowing multiple stakeholders to build out a merits process. Workday provides benchmarking data from multiple sources to help management craft a compensation strategy that’s equitable and competitive for the industry.

External benchmarking data provides insights into pay range and its relation to retention, for example. Workday has additional built-in tools to help a company continuously refine its compensation strategy:

  • Pay equity dashboards.
  • Compensation analysis.
  • Compensation review.
  • Executive compensation.
The Workday platform shows the pay equity dashboard with bar and circle graphs visualizing analytics like average compensation data by gender.
Workday’s compensation management tools are set up for collaborative strategizing, execution, and refinement. The Pay Equity dashboard, for example, helps HR monitor the pulse of pay equity in the organization. Credit: Workday

Like most HCM solutions, Workday does not disclose its price. However, most outlets indicate Workday is on the high end, costing as much as $300,000 annually or between $40 to $60 per employee, per month (PEPM).

This does not include Workday’s one-time implementation fee, which can be one to two times more than your annual subscription fee.

Workday HCM is excellent for organizations needing to develop a comprehensive compensation strategy by comparing industry benchmarks against employee performance data. Combined with Workday’s finance features, companies can see how changing employee pay impacts the bottom line. As a result, HR teams can craft a strategy that rewards top performers, promotes pay equity, and allows the business to remain profitable.

How to choose the best HCM software

To strategize and execute on the areas of HR that spell long-term growth for the company as a whole, a company needs to invest in the right solution that fits its priorities and goals. These HCM solutions support most or all the key areas that HR needs in order to successfully align people with business goals.

However, these are just a sampling of the top HCM vendors on the market, so if none of them address your current approach to HR strategy, check out our HR Software Guide.


Lauren Hansen Avatar

About the author


Featured partners: HR software

GoCo

Visit website

Elevate your HR with a modern, easy-to-use HRIS designed for small businesses. GoCo is a secure, compliant hub for sending, digitally signing, and organizing your sensitive HR documents and data. Manage records, performance, time off, onboarding, benefits, and more – all in one place. With the best support in the industry, every GoCo customer is assigned a dedicated Customer Success Team that is readily available to provide guidance and ensure a smooth and reliable HRIS experience.

Learn more about GoCo

Paycor

Visit website

Paycor’s HR software modernizes every aspect of people management, which saves leaders time and gives them the powerful analytics they need to build winning teams. Paycor provides a full suite of HCM solutions with a single source of truth for employee data, so users never have to switch platforms, log-in to multiple systems, re-key data or open multiple spreadsheets. Everyday processes become simplified, allowing organizations to focus on their most important work.

Learn more about Paycor

Rippling

Visit website

Rippling is the first way for businesses to manage all of their HR, IT, and Finance — payroll, benefits, computers, apps, corporate cards, expenses, and more — in one unified workforce platform. By connecting every business system to one source of truth for employee data, businesses can automate all of the manual work they normally need to do to make employee changes.

Learn more about Rippling

Browse all HR software →

TechnologyAdvice is able to offer our services for free because some vendors may pay us for web traffic or other sales opportunities. Our mission is to help technology buyers make better purchasing decisions, so we provide you with information for all vendors — even those that don't pay us.
In this article...