January 10, 2024

Top Contractor Payroll Solutions 2024

Written by
Why is TechnologyAdvice Free?

Here are our picks for the top contractor payroll solutions:

  • Rippling is best for growing companies looking for features to accommodate the entire contractor and employee life cycle.
  • Gusto is best for contractor self-service features so companies can onboard and get their contractors started on projects quickly and easily.
  • QuickBooks Payroll is best for smaller companies needing to manage their contractor and business transactions all in one place.
  • Deel is best for companies needing payroll and benefits support for their international contractors.
  • Justworks is best for companies wishing to minimize compliance risks by outsourcing contractor and employee payroll.

Software Spotlight: QuickBooks PayrollSPONSORED

Intuit QuickBooks supports various small business needs, from accounting to employee management. The best part is that if you only hire contractors, you can access these tools at a more affordable price than the other vendors in this roundup.

Some of the other benefits of choosing QuickBooks Payroll include:

  • 50% off your subscription plan for the first three months.
  • Lower-cost subscription bundles for payroll and accounting.
  • Next-day direct deposits for faster contractor and employee payments.
  • Contractor portals for submitting W-9s and setting up direct deposit.
  • Visit QuickBooks Payroll

    May 21, 2024:  Jessica Dennis added a sponsored callout box highlighting the contractor payroll features of QuickBooks Payroll. She also updated the cons for Justworks.

    Jan. 10, 2024: Jessica Dennis added a video overview to the article.

    Sept. 27, 2023: We updated the formatting of the page to improve the visual flow of information. We also added details about Rippling’s limited-time free trial offer.

    We picked our choices with you in mind.

    First, we evaluated several contractor payroll solutions based on today’s market and the reviews of customers like you. We then narrowed our selections to the platforms that best addressed your top-of-mind concerns, such as cost per contractor, user experience, direct deposit capability, and tax compliance.

    As the market changes, we reevaluate our choices so you always receive the best insight for your purchasing decision.

    Check out our Payroll Software Guide for our full selection of payroll software options on the market today. You can also watch our video overview of the top contractor payroll solutions below.

    What is the top contractor payroll software?

    Contractor payroll software allows companies to easily pay their contingent workers, such as independent contractors, gig workers, freelancers, and consultants. It also offers options for companies to collect and store invoices, tackle payments to subcontractors, file tax documentation, and track time.

    Our roundup of top contractor payroll software offers solutions for companies with varying contractor payment concerns so you know you’re getting the best software to fit the needs of your business.

    Contractor-only plan? Starting price
    Rippling No $35/mo. + $8/user/mo. Visit Rippling
    Gusto Yes $35/mo. + $6/contractor/mo. Visit Gusto
    QuickBooks Payroll Yes $15/contractor/mo. Visit QuickBooks
    Deel Yes $49/contractor/mo. Visit Deel
    Justworks No $59/employee/mo. Visit Justworks

    Rippling: Best for managing the contractor-to-employee life cycle

    The Rippling logo.

    Rippling is an all-in-one HR software suite with modules in payroll, benefits administration, recruitment, and learning management. With Rippling, companies can automate their payroll processes, including federal, state, and local tax filings and new hire reporting in all 50 states. Rippling even automatically requests and gathers compliance documents from contractors and employees and stores them electronically for record-keeping.

    Because of its diverse catalog of features, Rippling can accommodate businesses that expect to move beyond basic payroll functions for their contractors. For example, companies can add modules with more advanced features as business needs for their contractors’ scale, such as international payroll support. Companies can also purchase, configure, and ship company equipment to remote contractors with Rippling’s IT features. As a result, contractors have the tools to produce quality work on par with the company’s employees.

    Pros

    • Automatic tax filings for employees and contractors.
    • Robust reporting, with options for pre-made or customized reports.
    • Over 500 integrations, including QuickBooks and NetSuite for accounting.
    • Expense management module for both domestic and international workers.
    • Payment to contractors in over 50 countries, with dynamic currency conversion.
    • Options for EOR and PEO services.

    Cons

    • Confusing, non-transparent pricing.
    • Global payroll and time-tracking are add-ons.
    • Companies must subscribe to the Rippling Unity workforce platform before accessing payroll options.

    Key features

    Modular add-on features: Companies can add additional Rippling modules as their business needs expand and change. By leveraging modules like recruitment and performance management, companies can streamline their onboarding and retention processes to create a consistent experience for contractors at every stage of their employment relationship.

    Contractor misclassification support: Similar to Justworks and Deel, Rippling incorporates compliance features into every aspect of its software — such as offering guidance to companies on when to switch contractors over to employees. Rippling users can even sign up for Rippling’s EOR or PEO services, which provide the best of Justworks and Deel to drastically reduce their chances of worker misclassification.

    When processing domestic and international contractor and employee payrolls, Rippling’s Compliance 360 automatically alerts users of potential labor law violations so companies can prevent situations before they happen. Source: Rippling

    Why we chose Rippling

    Rippling allows businesses to combine their disparate HR software into one and layer on advanced talent and performance management functionality as needed. In this way, companies can effectively manage contractor payments while fostering positive contractor-employer relationships. Thus, Rippling is a great option to support contractors from the start to the end of their projects with the company.

    Rippling is offering a one-month free trial for a limited time — sign up before December 1, 2023, to take advantage of this deal.

    Gusto: Best for contractor self-service features

    Gusto is notable for its ability to run both contractor and employee payrolls in one place without HR teams switching between their human resources information systems (HRIS) and accounting software.

    However, Gusto also includes a contractor-only price plan, so employers do not have to pay extra for employee support when they do not need it. Gusto also automatically sends payday emails to contractors, processes and files end-of-the-year tax documents, and reports contractor new hire reporting in the states that require it.

    For an additional fee, companies can even add features to engage their remote or international contractors. For instance, Gusto lets HR teams conduct engagement surveys to gather feedback. As a result, contractors feel like they have a voice in company matters and are more connected to their teams and the company overall.

    Pros

    • Contractor payments in over 120 countries.
    • Automatic 1099 filing on companies’ behalf.
    • State new hire reporting on companies’ behalf (if required).
    • Integration with accounting software, including QuickBooks and Xero.
    • Contractor project time tracking on Plus and Premium plans.

    Cons

    • Back-up withholding is not included in the contractor-only plan.
    • 4-day direct deposit.
    • International contractor payroll is an add-on for an additional fee.
    • Outside of global contractor payroll, other add-on features are unavailable on contractor-only plans.
    • Users report poor customer service experiences.

    Key features

    Self-onboarding: Contractors can follow a simple, online onboarding checklist in Gusto so companies can avoid collecting physical forms such as W-9s. Gusto then consolidates this information so companies can track and process employee and contractor information for greater efficiency during payroll.

    Project time tracking: In Gusto’s Plus and Premium plans, managers can easily assign projects that contractors can easily track by logging on through their computers or using Gusto’s mobile app. These hours then sync with payroll so managers and HR teams can review and approve for payment. 

    Alternatively, Gusto integrates with popular time-tracking platforms, including Connecteam, QuickBooks Time, and Clock Shark. This allows contractors to use their favorite time-tracking system when billing their hours.

    Contractors can easily track their hours for assigned projects through Gusto’s time-tracking feature to ensure they receive proper payment. Source: Gusto

    Why we chose Gusto

    Gusto rates highly for its affordability and vast payroll capabilities optimized for small to medium businesses. Gusto can also support companies with various pay schedules, employee classifications, and tax regulations. With Gusto’s added self-service features to help contractors operate independently, we find Gusto to be one of the best contractor payroll applications that foster more efficient HR teams.

    Gusto is our frequent favorite for its simple-to-use platform and speedy payroll processes. Learn more about Gusto and its competitors in our list of Top Payroll Software.

    QuickBooks Payroll: Best for consolidating contractor and business transactions

    The QuickBooks logo.

    For small businesses with limited budgets, HR teams, or accounting staff, QuickBooks Payroll is an ideal solution for their contractor payroll. Not only is it an affordable option that includes a 30-day free trial, but it easily integrates with Intuit’s complete line of products for small businesses, such as accounting and time-tracking.

    Although companies have to pay extra for QuickBooks to file contractor 1099s, QuickBooks Payroll automatically tracks and prepares 1099s so companies can easily categorize, e-file, and send them to their contractors and vendors at the end of the year. Contractors can also create a free account with QuickBooks to submit W-9s and access their year-end tax documents at their convenience.

    QuickBooks Payroll’s Contractor Payments + Simple Start subscription tier provides core business management features, which are especially appealing to small businesses. For example, companies can transfer contractor payments and other business transactions, such as income, expenses, and vendor payments, to their general ledgers. As a result, companies can easily view their financial health and make decisions to improve business practices at any time.

    Pros

    • Next-day direct deposit.
    • Integration with a full range of QuickBooks accounting and time-tracking software solutions.
    • Affordable for small teams, including a 30-day free trial.
    • Mobile app option.

    Cons

    • Limited integrations outside of Intuit products.
    • Extra fees apply for QuickBooks to e-file 1099s and send them to contractors on companies’ behalf.
    • More advanced accounting features are only accessible on Contractor Payments + Simple Start plan.

    Key features

    Accounting integration: QuickBooks Payroll allows companies to integrate with their powerful accounting software to streamline all business transactions in one place, including mileage tracking, invoicing, and expense reporting.

    Niche industry support: QuickBooks Payroll offers specialized products supporting contractors in construction, nonprofits, and manufacturing. With features like job costing and inventory tracking, companies can use QuickBooks to handle their industries’ unique concerns without additional software.

    Learn how to pay contractors with QuickBooks:

    Why we chose QuickBooks Payroll

    QuickBooks is a popular accounting software among small businesses because of its tax assistance, intuitive interface, and core functionality in invoicing, time-tracking, and point-of-sale. Thus, it is easy for companies to move from QuickBooks’s accounting-only features into managing payroll for their contractors and employees, making it an important product to include in our top five list.

    If you’re looking for the most affordable payroll options on the market, check out our Best Free Payroll Software shortlist.

    Deel: Best for paying international contractors

    Deel started as a payroll solution for handling international contractor payments. As a result, its features make sending and receiving global contractor payments a simplified experience for employers and contractors alike.

    Deel supports hiring and paying contractors in over 150 countries. Companies also receive a dedicated customer service manager to assist them with hiring, onboarding, and payroll compliance in each country. For small companies without a dedicated HR team, the extra assistance Deel provides is a major plus in mitigating risk.

    Moreover, Deel makes it easy for contractors to get paid and access their money directly on the platform. Contractors can submit invoices and add time adjustments in Deel at any time. In addition, they can choose from multiple payment methods, including ACH transfer, cryptocurrency, or pay cards. These convenient options reduce contractors’ administrative work so they can focus on providing quality service for their clients.

    Pros

    • Automatic payroll for contractors, employer of record (EOR) employees, and direct employees.
    • Management of data processing agreements for privacy laws worldwide, including GDPR.
    • 5+ methods to pay contractors, including direct deposit and cryptocurrency.
    • Perk options specifically for contractors.
    • Contractors can get paid up to 30 days ahead of time with Deel advance.
    • Ability to pay contractors in over 150 countries.
    • Assigned customer service manager.

    Cons

    • Limited HR functionality outside of personnel database and reporting.
    • Expensive to move to an EOR plan ($599 per employee per month).
    • No time-tracking module for contractors.

    Key features

    Global compliance: Companies can create and send localized contracts, collect and store onboarding and tax documentation, and manage benefits compliantly within Deel. For added protection, companies can leverage Deel Shield to eliminate the risk of contractor misclassification by letting Deel hire and classify their workers on their behalf. 

    Worldwide contractor perks: Although employers are not required to offer benefits or perks to their contractors, Deel provides them at no extra charge. From the Deel pay card to health insurance discounts and stock options, employers can improve the experience with their contractors and increase the likelihood of them returning for future work and projects.

    Learn more about Deel’s contractor features:

    Why we chose Deel

    Although Deel lacks the advanced HR functionality of other vendors like Gusto and Rippling, it provides the most support for international contractors. With multiple payment methods and perks just for contractors, Deel stands out among competitors in the space.

    Need help with your global payroll? Check out Deel and its competitors in our Top Global Payroll Solutions list.

    Justworks: Best for managed contractor and employee payroll

    Justworks is both a product and a service, combining the tools of an HR software with the assistance of a professional employer organization (PEO). This means that companies that partner with Justworks receive access to a simple but powerful human resources information system (HRIS) and the expertise of HR professionals to reduce compliance risk and repetitive administrative tasks.

    From Justworks’s homepage, companies can quickly access core HR functions, including payroll, benefits, and workforce management. In addition, companies can process expense reimbursements from Justworks’s payments center and schedule off-cycle payroll runs for their contractors and vendors. Justworks also allows companies to migrate payment data through a QuickBooks or Xero integration to keep track of their labor costs and simplify payroll audit processes.

    Pros

    • Benefits of a PEO, including reduced liability through a co-employment relationship.
    • Payment to employees, contractors, and vendors from the same platform.
    • Year-end 1099 paperwork issued for bother contractors and vendors.
    • 24/7 support through phone, email, chat, Slack, or SMS.

    Cons

    • PEO and international contractor services are currently managed in two separate systems.
    • Justworks Hours for time tracking is an additional $8 per user monthly.

    Key features

    Vendor and independent contractor support: Justworks automates payroll for employees, contractors, and vendors to prevent the need for separate HR, finance, or accounting software. In addition, Justworks’s payments center allows companies to pay their vendors at a time most convenient to them, even outside of a payroll run, for ultimate control over their cashflows.

    EPLI and HR consulting: Besides 24/7 support, companies have extra protection with Justworks’ HR consulting. Companies can contact Justworks HR experts for help with contractor and employee classification, payroll, offer letters, or policy writing questions. 

    Plus, with the added protection of Employment Practices Liability Insurance (EPLI), Justworks can cover and aid employers in the event of an employment-related lawsuit.

    Watch a demo of Justworks’ software:

    Why we chose Justworks

    Although Justworks software is more bare-bones than some of its competitors, it is extremely well-liked by users for its uncomplicated user interface and responsive customer service. 

    And for startups or small businesses juggling diverse worker classifications, Justworks provides peace of mind with 24/7 customer support, automatic tax filings, and contractor regulation monitoring. This makes Justworks a clear winner for companies interested in a managed payroll solution.

    Visit Justworks

    How to choose the top contractor payroll solution

    The best contractor payroll solution allows companies to run both their employee and contractor payroll services in one place while easily tracking, creating, and filing necessary tax documents. Although all of our top picks offer these features, they stand out from the crowd for their compliance support, international capabilities, and flexible add-ons.

    • Go with Rippling for modules to support your contractors’ growth with your business.
    • Choose Gusto if you value quick implementation and contractor self-service features.
    • Choose QuickBooks Payroll for an affordable contractor and accounting solution.
    • Select Deel if you need to hire contractors abroad.
    • Pick Justworks if your small business requires managed contractor and employee payroll services.

    However, if none of these solutions meet your needs, check out our Payroll Software Guide for a comprehensive list of options


    Jessica Dennis Avatar

    About the author


    Featured partners

    1 Deel

    Visit website

    Run payroll in 100+ countries and 200+ currencies from a single place. Deel’s comprehensive global platform eliminates the ongoing admin of local compliance, taxes, and benefits. With in-house experts across 100+ countries, dedicated CSM’s, visa and PTO support, and more, Deel provides unmatched payroll expertise and service. Plus, with a single point of contact, we eliminate handovers, providing you with faster support and compliance, so your entire global team gets paid quickly and securely.

    Learn more about Deel

    2 Paycor

    Visit website

    Paycor’s HR software modernizes every aspect of people management, which saves leaders time and gives them the powerful analytics they need to build winning teams. Paycor provides a full suite of HCM solutions with a single source of truth for employee data, so users never have to switch platforms, log-in to multiple systems, re-key data or open multiple spreadsheets. Everyday processes become simplified, allowing organizations to focus on their most important work.

    Learn more about Paycor

    3 Multiplier Technologies

    Visit website

    With Multiplier, pay any number of global employees easily in multiple currencies. Eliminate the hassle of maintaining individual providers per country. Generate a single invoice and pay international teams in minutes. Have a consolidated dashboard to manage global payroll from a single window.

    Learn more about Multiplier Technologies

    Browse all payroll software →

    TechnologyAdvice is able to offer our services for free because some vendors may pay us for web traffic or other sales opportunities. Our mission is to help technology buyers make better purchasing decisions, so we provide you with information for all vendors — even those that don't pay us.
    In this article...