Compare 2015's Best PPM Software
Answer a few questions to receive free recommendations and price quotes
Do you currently use Project Portfolio Management software?
Compare Project Portfolio Management Solutions Side by Side
Choose from our list of vendors below
TechnologyAdvice Buyer’s Guide to Project and Portfolio Management Software
The complexity of large projects makes successful project management a challenge for most companies. Poor project management means projects finish past due dates, over-budget, and with a lower-than-predicted return on investment (ROI). To overcome these challenges, businesses often rely on project management software, which mitigates risk by identifying failing aspects of a project.
Project management software can help streamline your company’s processes and create a successful PM framework. But as your project management process matures and you’re able to take on more projects, it becomes difficult to oversee multiple endeavors.
For example, when there are fifty projects in progress, how do you decide where to invest your organization’s time, budget, and staff? Which product, service, or new idea is top priority? How can you monitor a variety of important projects to ensure their chances of success are maximized?
Decision making in an ever changing climate demands a central platform to manage overall project efforts. Project portfolio management (PPM) software provides visibility, oversight, and tools to help companies prioritize and manage current projects and resources, as well as future needs and demands.
According to a study from the Aberdeen Group, organizations that use a PPM tool are 44 percent more likely to complete projects on time or early, 38 percent more likely to complete projects on budget, and 52 percent more likely to hit the expected ROI.1 Additionally, a study from Forrester Research Group concluded that implementing a PPM solution produced an expected ROI of 255 percent.2
In short, PPM software provides project managers and executives in large, project-driven organizations with a way to manage investments across a portfolio of assets to ensure maximum return on capital. The worldwide project and portfolio management market grew to $3.9 billion in 2013, and IDC’s forecasts show continued growth of 7.8 percent to reach $5.7 billion by 2018.3
PPM Software Comparison
|Product||User Rating||Pricing Tier||Native Mobile App?||Free Trial?|
|Project Portfolio Office||n/a||average||no||yes|
PM vs EPM vs PPM
If you already use project management software — or even a good project-driven ERP system — then it’s natural to question whether or not you actually need project and portfolio management software. To add to the confusion, some vendors sell each of these systems as separate applications, while others offer an all-in-one product. So can one platform really do the job as three — and save you software licensing costs?
Let’s examine the difference between these systems and sort out which software is best for your business.
Project management software involves functionality aimed at day-to-day project planning, tracking, and monitoring. A project manager is interested in immediate priorities — who is supposed to do what activity and by when. These tools help teams collaborate and increase transparency through features such as milestones, Gantt charts, budgeting, calendars, and timesheets.
Enterprise project management software is also designed to facilitate day-to-day project delivery and management, but on a larger scale. Since enterprises have more than one project in progress simultaneously, an EPM solution helps to manage, monitor, and assess the activities, schedules, and work breakdown structures for the company’s existing set of projects among all departments.
PPM: Portfolio project management software
Portfolio project management software is designed to handle overarching projects, programs, or products. PPM systems show performance and resource demands of current projects, as well as projects that are being bid, sold, or will start at a future date. PPM systems show the dependencies between projects and the rest of the enterprise, so project managers and executives have a global view of where skills and resources are invested. PPM software generally aggregates project data from PM, EPM, or ERP systems to create portfolios (organized per budget size, calendar year, budget year, business line, etc.) of existing and future projects for evaluation.
Since PPM products provide a zoomed-out view of projects, some vendors may lack the tools needed to manage the granular aspects of an individual project or sub-project. Additionally, as technology rapidly advances, many ERP vendors are capable of delivering the functionality of PPM, EPM, or both — which further complicates the buying process.
So now you have some PPM and EPM solutions that are essentially the same thing, just re-labeled, depending on the industry to which vendors are trying to market them.4
Don’t necessarily judge a system by its acronym. Instead, focus on pinpointing the goals and need of your business, then evaluate and choose a project portfolio management software vendor that meets your specific needs.
Comparing Portfolio Project Management Software
If you’re not sure what to look for, it’s easy to get overwhelmed when you compare project portfolio management software. PPM systems are essentially designed to do the same job, so differentiating between platforms is a challenge. In addition to PPM, some mega-vendors offer PM suites, EPM suites, and full ERP systems. Others only offer standalone PPM software that extracts data from your existing project management software, while still others provide niche systems tailored to your industry.
Ultimately, the best software for your business depends on the overall functionality and integrations you need. To understand how a PPM system can be used to meet your objectives, it’s important to understand the core functionality it provides. PPM software typically includes the following key management capabilities:
Sometimes called pipeline assessment and analysis, this feature helps managers determine whether a project or a set of projects can be finished with the time and resources on hand. A constant, real-time overview of projects and resources allows you to assess which endeavors contribute to business objectives and determine the best way to invest accordingly.
With a 10,000 foot view of your project pipeline, you can efficiently allocate company resources to projects as needed. Sometimes called demand or resource management, this allows you to manage and distribute financial, inventory, technical, and human resource. In addition to offering resource allocation on an individual project basis, many systems allow you to model ‘what-if’ scenarios and apply them across the entire portfolio.
One major reason many projects fail is because new requirements, features, operational constraints, regulatory demands, or technical alterations crop up mid-project. These fluctuations in project details often force projects to go over budget or past deadlines. To overcome this, PPM software provides a central repository for various change requests. This allows you to quickly assess inquiries as they arise, and match available resources to overall demand. Additionally, change management allows you to monitor project timelines and budgets in real-time.
Your financial manager needs to accurately estimate and manage the financial resources and anticipated outcome from company projects. Most PPM systems can demonstrate the anticipated financial value of projects in relation to strategic objectives and organizational priorities. Financial management capabilities let you see updated financial progress as it happens, which allows you to — before project completion — more accurately predict if a project will fail to meet financial objectives . If you are able to determine when projects will fall short of financial expectations, you can change the parameters or cease investment before incurring losses.
PPM software allows you to analyze the risk present in each existing and potential project to determine confidence levels across the portfolio. By grouping projects together, you can evaluate confidence levels on a categorical basis, and assist financial and resource allocation decisions. Sometimes referred to as “portfolio change and risk management,” the benefit of this feature is the ability to determine which projects — or even which facets of individual projects — are too risky. Using risk regulation modules prior to launching a project can help your organization avoid poor investments.
At the core of a PPM system, the above features are made possible by company-wide analysis capabilities. A self-service reporting dashboard provides a top-level view of projects, resources, budgets, requirements, and timelines. Analysis, predictive functionality, and “what-if” scenarios provide cohesive insights across investments to help leadership determine which efforts have the best prospects for high returns, assess the impact of changes to the portfolio, and reveal potential interdependencies. Project performance metrics from real-time data aggregation increase transparency.
In addition to analytics, other important PPM aspects to consider are:
- Deployment options
- Mobile Access
- Global support
- Software integrations
- IT project-specific functionality
- New features release schedule
- Capability-based best practices
- Additional PM or ERP modules
Common PPM Applications
Though it’s primarily adopted by enterprises, about 17 percent of mid-market companies use project portfolio management software.5 SMBs should focus on adopting a standard PM process and centralizing all project data before looking to leverage PPM software.
Most software markets are divided into tiers based on company size, but when choosing a PPM system, functionality mostly varies with use case. Depending on your industry and goals, your priorities will vary. Below are a few common PPM applications that may require an industry-specific vendor.
- IT / software development
- Product development
- Marketing agencies
How to Create Executive Buy-In
Gaining buy-in from executives is a critical success factor for software approval and implementation. In order to get your software purchase approved, you’ll need to include data that shows stakeholders what kind of return on investment they can expect. To do this, you can use the statistics provided in the introduction of this guide, and present industry research and relevant case studies like the one below. Additionally, consider tailoring your appeal to address the concerns of each member of the C-suite. Here some talking points to get you started.
Your IT department ensures the technology needs of the organizations are met. It’s important to consult your chief technology officer early in the buying process so they can share their expertise and help you make an informed decision. Since IT is constantly changing, there are many advantages to adopting modern PPM software. In the case of cloud deployment, IT can save costs on infrastructure, as well as reduce the burden on IT resources. Since the managers and stakeholders can use self-service PPM to monitor projects, the time IT spends on running reports is reduced. The IT department will be concerned with hidden costs (such as customer service bills) and security. Consulting IT early will ensure you have the support you need and a contender list that meets their rigorous requirements.
The leader of your organization sets the strategic goals and understands how projects align with those goals. Portfolio project management software can give them a data-driven way to monitor, evaluate, and predict project success, which helps your company identify what’s working and what’s not. It also provides an overview of your entire portfolio of projects, so leadership doesn’t have to wait for a report to know where everything stands. This leads to improved resource utilization and faster project completion, which is important for maintaining a competitive edge.
Your chief financial officer ensures resources that are allocated to projects align with the organization’s priorities. Since projects are often a large capital investment and sometimes uncertain, CFOs understand the importance of project success. They will want to know the funding requirements for a new technology investment, and how it will generate revenue. Be sure to highlight reduction in budget overruns for successful projects and avoidance of low value projects possible with PPM software. Case studies featuring companies similar to yours can help CFOs understand the financial benefits of investing in this technology.
Project Portfolio Management Software Case Study
Solution: CA PPM (formerly CA Clarity PPM)
Finansbank is a Turkish bank with over 674 branches and 13,697 employees. In 2005, their IT department became a separate subsidiary known as IBTech. IBTech is responsible for Finansbank’s IT infrastructure design, application development, and service management model.
IBTech designs and develops Finansbank’s Core Banking solution, as well as new platforms such as mobile banking, social networking, fraud detection solutions, and a next generation contact centre solution. They also manage projects that ensure the bank remains compliant with legislation.
As IBTech’s project management maturity increased, their existing project management software needed greater functionality and configurability to streamline key processes and enable automation. Reporting, financial management, and invoicing were particularly challenging, since IBTech had to export data and manually calculate costs. IBTech wanted to improve its ability to plan resource capacity in advance and simplify charge-back processes.
IBTech required a user-friendly, highly configurable, and easy to integrate solution to fulfill their functional requirements for project, portfolio, resource, and financial management. They selected CA Project and Portfolio Management after spending 18 months evaluating portfolio project management vendors, attending workshops, and evaluating requests for proposals.
“The projects we manage on behalf of Finansbank are key to its day-to-day operations and competitive advantage. CA Project & Portfolio Management enables us to deliver better and quicker project-based services and information to Finansbank, which in turn means Finansbank can offer rapid and more efficient technology-based services to its customers.” -Metin Ornek, Manager, Department of Planning and Analysis
In addition to gaining the ability to make more informed business and investment decisions, IBTech saw the following results after implementation:
- Migrated seven years of Microsoft Project data, including 10 million financial transactions, which resulted in centralized project data and historical information
- System is used by over 50 project managers, 30 resource managers, and 200 team members on a daily basis
- Gained real-time view and control of 500 IT projects and access to records for 2,500 live and archived projects
- Adopted a stage gate system to track deliverables and automate approvals processes, which identifies recurring bottlenecks and prevent delays
- Increased efficiency through integrations that automatically produce reports and eliminate manual data duplication
- Portfolio reporting reduced from one week to one hour
- Charge-back reporting reduced from two weeks to three hours
- Resource capacity reporting reduced from several weeks to just minutes
- Increased accuracy and efficiency of customer billing
- Improve resource allocation and capacity management
- Gained greater control to improve data governance and ensure compliance
Choosing the Best Portfolio Project Management Software
At TechnologyAdvice, our goal is to help businesses connect with the technology that best meets their needs. We’ve compiled product information, reviews, case studies, feature lists, video walkthroughs, and research articles on hundreds of leading IT solutions, all to make the buying process more straightforward for decision makers like you.
If you’re curious about any of the portfolio project management products or features listed in this guide, we’d love to talk to you. Call one of our in-house specialists for a free consultation, or use the Product Selection Tool on our website to get a personalized recommendation.
- Braunack, Jamie-Lee. “6 Project Portfolio Management Stats to Help Sell PPM Internally.” Eclipse PPM. December 20, 2012. http://info.eclipseppm.com/blog/bid/167985/6-Project-Portfolio-Management-Stats-to-Help-Sell-PPM-Internally
- “The Executive Buyer’s Guide to PPM.” Innotas. Accessed May 26, 2015. http://www.bpmvision.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2013/04/The-Executive-Buyers-guide-to-perfect-portfolio-management.pdf
- “Worldwide Project and Portfolio Management 2014–2018 Forecast and 2013 Vendor Shares: Ongoing Growth Driven by Demand.” IDC: Analyze the Future. Accessed May 26, 2015. http://www.idc.com/getdoc.jsp?containerId=250602
- Ingram, Kenny. “Do You Really Need Project Portfolio Management Software?” Industry Week. Accessed May 26, 2015. http://www.industryweek.com/systems-integration/do-you-really-need-project-portfolio-management-software
- Caretta, Kristen. “With PPM software, don’t always throw in the kitchen sink.” TechTarget. July 17, 2009. http://itknowledgeexchange.techtarget.com/cio/with-ppm-software-dont-always-throw-in-the-kitchen-sink/
- “Finansbank Enhances Competitive Advantage with Greater Control of 500 IT Projects.” CA Technologies. Customer Case Study October 2010. http://www.ca.com/us/~/media/Files/SuccessStories/ca-css-finansbank-300614-cs-eng.pdf